Research article summary:

Neurological origins of poor reading comprehension despite fast word decoding?

Abstract Extract:
Barnes, Faulkner, and Dennis (2001) found that hydrocephalic children (mean age = 11.5 years) of average or above-average verbal intelligence exhibit poor reading comprehension despite their fast and accurate decoding skills on individual words. This ... (Full abstract text below)

Published 2002Feb in Journal: Brain Lang (Language : eng)

Full Pubmed Extract

This information was retrieved, real-time, on your behalf from the public area of the Pubmed website:

1. Brain Lang. 2002 Feb;80(2):253-9

Neurological origins of poor reading comprehension despite fast word decoding?

Yamada J

Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan. junyamd@hiroshima-u.ac.jp

Barnes, Faulkner, and Dennis (2001) found that hydrocephalic children (mean age = 11.5 years) of average or above-average verbal intelligence exhibit poor reading comprehension despite their fast and accurate decoding skills on individual words. This finding attracts the attention of reading researchers because it appears to be against the following standard principle of reading comprehension failure (Gough & Hillinger, 1980), thereby provoking basic issues centering around it (e.g., Stanovich, 1991): Reading Comprehension = Word Decoding x Listening Comprehension. This formula indicates that when listening comprehension is kept well within the normal range, reading comprehension is highly correlated with word decoding (e.g., Perfetti, 1985). In contrast, with poor listening comprehension children would be poor readers however good they may be at reading words (e.g., Cain, Oakhill, & Bryant, 2000). Although Barnes et al. clearly demonstrated that children with hydrocephalus decoded individual words better than they comprehended text, it is not readily apparent whether their findings are inconsistent with the standard principle. The purpose of the present article is twofold. The first is to examine whether Barnes et al.'s findings constitute a counterexample of the above principle. (Note that Barnes et al. did not address this question.) The second and more important purpose is to discuss the possible origins of the decoding-better-than-sentence/text-comprehension pattern. We also present some pedagogical implications for poor readers such as hydrocephalic children.

PMID : 11827447 [PubMed - Indexed for MEDLINE]

This information is obtained from the National Library of Medicine (NLM). Abstract text and other information may be subject to copyright. Type "NLM copyright" into Google for more information.

Full Author Information

First Name	LastName	Initials
Jun	Yamada	J

Affiliation: Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan. junyamd@hiroshima-u.ac.jp

3rd Party provider links

Click the links below to go to related 3rd party information:

MESH categories and related page links

This article was linked to the MESH categories shown on the left below. The links on the right are related Memletics pages.

Category links from this article:

Child
Cognition
Humans
Hydrocephalus
Reading
Vocabulary

Links for this article

For links to places where you can get the full text of this article see links. Note there may be a subscription or fee required for access to the full text.

New! Using similar technology to this site, we have launched find-health-articles.com, targeting over 1 million health research article abstracts.

Here are some articles related to this one (by title keywords):

Older adults filter irrelevant information during metaphor comprehension.

Language comprehenders mentally represent the shapes of objects.

The extraction of structure during reading: evidence from reading prosody.

Effects of text difficulty and adults age on relative calibration of comprehension.

Distinct patterns of neural modulation during the processing of conceptual and syntactic anomalies.

The costs of freedom: an ERP -- study of non-canonical sentences.

Comprehension of written health care information in an affluent geriatric retirement community: use of the Test of Functional Health Literacy.

Changes in childrens voices: the effect of cognitive cues.

Basic Reading Through Dance program. The impact on first-grade students basic reading skills.

Structure of preschool phonological sensitivity: overlapping sensitivity to rhyme, words, syllables, and phonemes.

>>> Get more research article abstracts like these, or browse abstracts.

Keywords in this article:

above, accurate, address, against, age, apparent, appears, around, article, attention, attracts, average, barnes, basic, better, bryant, cain, centering, children, clearly, comprehended, comprehension, constitute, contrast, correlated, counterexample, decoded, decoding, demonstrated, dennis, despite, discuss, examine, exhibit, failure, fast, faulkner, finding, findings, first, following, formula, good, gough, highly, hillinger, hydrocephalic, hydrocephalus, implications, important, inconsistent, indicates, individual, intelligence, issues, kept, listening, mean, more, normal, not, note, oakhill, or, origins, pattern, pedagogical, perfetti, poor, possible, present, principle, provoking, purpose, question, range, readers, readily, reading, researchers, second, sentence, skills, standard, stanovich, text, thereby, twofold, verbal, well, whether, words, years

Also, see our new free speed reading online course (beta version)