Research article summary:

The doctors defense.

Abstract Extract:
The paper takes as its point of departure a relatively recent case which attracted publicity in Britain, concerning a doctor charged with (but acquitted of) the murder of his terminally ill patient, and critically examines the criminal law of England and ... (Full abstract text below)

Published 2002Oct in Journal: Mt Sinai J Med (Language : eng)

Full Pubmed Extract

This information was retrieved, real-time, on your behalf from the public area of the Pubmed website:

1. Mt Sinai J Med. 2002 Oct;69(5):317-28

The doctor's defense.

Tur RH

Oriel College, Oxford, United Kingdom.

The paper takes as its point of departure a relatively recent case which attracted publicity in Britain, concerning a doctor charged with (but acquitted of) the murder of his terminally ill patient, and critically examines the criminal law of England and Wales relating to homicide in the context of medical practice. While similar issues obviously arise in many other countries, no comparative study is attempted in the paper. However, the arguments which have been presented are of more than local interest. From an analysis of this case and others, it appears that there is in common law something which can be called the doctor s defense. It holds that a doctor may, when caring for a patient who is suffering great pain, lawfully administer pain-killing drugs, despite the fact that, as the doctor well knows, one certain or highly probable consequence will be to shorten the patient s life. Current justifications for this defense are either incoherent or too weak. Some require that different conceptions of intention be deployed, depending on whether the agent is a doctor or not. Others rely on the philosophically controversial doctrine of double effect. Still others invoke an implausible notion of minimal causation. All these justifications apply readily enough to morally and factually easy cases, but fail in hard cases where the need for some justification is most pressing. These justifications seem incapable of providing adequate guidance to prosecutors or trial judges. Absent principled and transparent justification, the English criminal justice system exhibits different outcomes on what appear to be broadly similar facts. It is disturbing that the law is uncertain and incapable of giving adequate guidance. A doctor, compelled by conscience to intervene to end a person s life, should certainly be ready and willing to face rigorous legal scrutiny, but the law applied should not be arbitrary and random, nor should the outcome turn solely or chiefly on prosecutorial discretion or the predilections of the trial judge. The hope is to find a better rationale for the doctor s defense through an analysis of professional ethics and the concept of a recourse role.

PMID : 12415326 [PubMed - Indexed for MEDLINE]

This information is obtained from the National Library of Medicine (NLM). Abstract text and other information may be subject to copyright. Type "NLM copyright" into Google for more information.

Full Author Information

First Name	LastName	Initials
Richard H S	Tur	RH

Affiliation: Oriel College, Oxford, United Kingdom.

3rd Party provider links

Click the links below to go to related 3rd party information:

MESH categories and related page links

This article was linked to the MESH categories shown on the left below. The links on the right are related Memletics pages.

Links for this article

For links to places where you can get the full text of this article see links. Note there may be a subscription or fee required for access to the full text.

New! Using similar technology to this site, we have launched find-health-articles.com, targeting over 1 million health research article abstracts.

Here are some articles related to this one (by title keywords):

Why do doctors attend traditional CME events if they dont change what they do in their surgeries? Evaluation of doctors reasons for attending a traditional CME programme.

The value of clinical judgement analysis for improving the quality of doctors prescribing decisions.

Usual source of care in preventive service use: a regular doctor versus a regular site.

Stress in doctors and dentists who teach.

Recruitment of doctors to non-standard grades in the NHS: analysis of job advertisements and survey of advertisers.

Pro re nata medication for psychoses: the knowledge and beliefs of doctors and nurses.

Patients and doctors: reformulating the UK health policy community?

Medical futility: predicting outcome of intensive care unit patients by nurses and doctors--a prospective comparative study.

A levels and intelligence as predictors of medical careers in UK doctors: 20 year prospective study.

Establishing a doctor of philosophy program in nursing in an historically black college or University.

>>> Get more research article abstracts like these, or browse abstracts.

Keywords in this article:

absent, acquitted, adequate, administer, agent, analysis, appears, applied, apply, arbitrary, arguments, arise, attempted, attracted, better, britain, broadly, called, caring, case, cases, causation, certain, certainly, charged, chiefly, common, comparative, compelled, conceptions, concerning, conscience, consequence, context, controversial, countries, criminal, critically, current, defense, departure, depending, deployed, despite, different, discretion, disturbing, doctor, doctrine, double, drugs, easy, effect, england, english, ethics, examines, exhibits, face, fact, facts, factually, fail, find, giving, great, guidance, hard, highly, his, holds, homicide, hope, ill, implausible, incapable, incoherent, intention, interest, intervene, invoke, issues, judges, justice, justifications, killing, knows, law, lawfully, legal, life, local, many, medical, minimal, morally, more, murder, need, not, notion, obviously, one, other, others, outcomes, pain, paper, patient, person, philosophically, point, practice, predilections, presented, pressing, principled, probable, professional, prosecutorial, prosecutors, providing, publicity, random, rationale, readily, ready, recent, recourse, relating, relatively, rely, require, rigorous, scrutiny, shorten, similar, solely, something, still, study, suffering, system, takes, terminally, too, transparent, trial, turn, uncertain, wales, weak, well, where, whether, who, will, willing

Also, see our new free speed reading online course (beta version)