|
Research article summary:
The brain-machine disanalogy revisited.
Abstract Extract:
Michael Conrad was a pioneer in investigating biological information processing. He believed that there are fundamental lessons to be learned from the structure and behavior of biological brains that we are far from understanding or have implemented in ... (Full abstract text below) Published 2002Jan
in Journal: Biosystems
(Language : eng)
Full Pubmed Extract
This information was retrieved, real-time, on your behalf from the public area of the Pubmed website:
1. Biosystems.
2002 Jan;64(1-3):127-40
The brain-machine disanalogy revisited.
Zeigler BP
ECE Department, Arizona Center for Integrative Modeling and Simulation, The University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA. zeigler@ece.arizona.edu
Michael Conrad was a pioneer in investigating biological information processing. He believed that there are fundamental lessons to be learned from the structure and behavior of biological brains that we are far from understanding or have implemented in our computers. Accumulation of advances in several fields have confirmed his views in broad outline but not necessarily in some of the strong forms he had tried to establish. For example, his assertion that programmable computers are intrinsically incapable of the brain's efficient and adaptive behavior has not received much examination. Yet, this is clearly a direction that could afford much insight into fundamental differences between brain and machine. In this paper, we pay tribute to Michael, by examining his pioneering thoughts on the brain-machine disanalogy in some depth and from the hindsight of a decade later. We argue that as long as we stay within the frame of reference of classical computation, it is not possible to confirm that programmability places a fundamental limitation on computing power, although the resources required to implement a programmable interface leave fewer resources for actual problem-solving work. However, if we abandon the classical computational frame and adopt one in which the user interacts with the system (artificial or natural) in real time, it becomes easier to examine the key attributes that Michael believed place biological brains on a higher plane of capability than artificial ones. While we then see some of these positive distinctions confirmed (e.g. the limitations of symbol manipulation systems in addressing real-world perception problems), we also see attributes in which the implementation in bioware constrains the behavior of real brains. We conclude by discussing how new insights are emerging, that look at the time-bound problem-solving constraints under which organisms have had to survive and how their so-called 'fast and frugal' faculties are tuned to the environments that coevolved with them. These directions open new paths for a multifaceted understanding of what biological brains do and what we can learn from them. We close by suggesting how the discrete event modeling and simulation paradigm offers a suitable medium for exploring these paths.
PMID : 11755495 [PubMed - Indexed for MEDLINE]
This information is obtained from the National Library of Medicine (NLM). Abstract text and other information may be subject to copyright. Type "NLM copyright" into Google for more information.
Full Author Information
| First Name | LastName | Initials |
| Bernard P | Zeigler | BP |
Affiliation: ECE Department, Arizona Center for Integrative Modeling and Simulation, The University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA. zeigler@ece.arizona.edu
3rd Party provider links
Click the links below to go to related 3rd party information:
MESH categories and related page links
This article was linked to the MESH categories shown on the left below. The links on the right are related Memletics pages.
Category links from this article: | | Related Memletics topics: |
Links for this articleFor links to places where you can get the full text of this article see links. Note there may be a subscription or fee required for access to the full text. New! Using similar technology to this site, we have launched find-health-articles.com, targeting over 1 million health research article abstracts. Related ArticlesHere are some articles related to this one (by title keywords): Keywords in this article:abandon, accumulation, actual, adaptive, addressing, adopt, advances, afford, argue, artificial, assertion, attributes, becomes, behavior, believed, biological, bioware, bound, brains, broad, called, capability, classical, clearly, close, coevolved, computation, computational, computers, computing, conclude, confirmed, conrad, constrains, constraints, decade, depth, differences, direction, directions, disanalogy, discrete, discussing, distinctions, easier, efficient, emerging, environments, establish, event, examination, examine, examining, example, exploring, faculties, far, fast, fewer, fields, forms, frame, frugal, fundamental, he, higher, hindsight, his, implementation, implemented, incapable, information, insight, insights, interacts, interface, intrinsically, investigating, key, later, learned, leave, lessons, limitation, limitations, long, look, machine, manipulation, medium, michael, modeling, much, multifaceted, natural, necessarily, new, not, offers, ones, open, organisms, outline, paper, paradigm, paths, pay, perception, pioneer, pioneering, places, plane, positive, possible, power, problem, problems, processing, programmability, programmable, real, received, reference, required, resources, see, simulation, solving, stay, strong, structure, suggesting, suitable, survive, symbol, system, systems, thoughts, time, tribute, tried, tuned, understanding, user, views, work, world, yet
|
